Compare prices within the same model year
2023
Prices for used Tesla Model Ys are currently competitive, with a wide range available. Many well-equipped models, particularly from 2021-2023, are listed below the overall market average, suggesting good value for buyers seeking pre-owned options.
Moderate
The Tesla Model Y market shows a healthy inventory with numerous competitive listings. Buyers are advised to leverage this by comparing options carefully, focusing on vehicles with lower mileage and strong deal scores. Don't hesitate to negotiate, as many vehicles have been on the market for a reasonable duration, indicating potential flexibility from sellers. The presence of newer model years (2025-2026) listed as 'used' presents unique opportunities, potentially for demo or lightly used vehicles, which could offer significant value.
This is the top-ranked deal due to its exceptional deal score, indicating it's priced very competitively. The extremely low mileage (under 1,000 miles) for a 2026 model year, even if listed as used, suggests it's likely a demo or very lightly used vehicle, offering near-new condition at a significant discount.
This deal is highly recommended for its outstanding deal score and significant estimated savings. The 2023 Performance model has very low mileage (just over 10,000 miles), making it an excellent value proposition for a nearly new electric SUV.
This 2023 Performance model offers a strong combination of price and mileage, resulting in a high deal score and substantial estimated savings. While it has been on the market for 55 days, its attractive pricing makes it a compelling option for buyers looking for a well-equipped Model Y.
This 2025 Performance model is a standout deal with a high deal score and low mileage (under 12,000 miles). Its relatively short time on market (16 days) suggests it's a desirable vehicle, and the estimated savings indicate a good price point for a newer model year.
This 2021 Performance model is a solid choice, offering a good deal score for its price and mileage. While the estimated savings are modest, its presence on the market for 55 days and its competitive price make it a reasonable option for those looking for a slightly older but still capable Model Y.
This 2022 Performance model is a great find, boasting a high deal score and significant estimated savings. With less than 27,000 miles, it offers a nearly new driving experience at a very attractive price, making it one of the best values on the list.
This 2025 Performance model is a fantastic deal, characterized by its very low mileage (under 6,100 miles) and a strong deal score. Its short time on market (19 days) suggests high demand, and the price offers good value for a nearly new vehicle.
This 2023 Performance model is a strong contender, offering a good deal score and substantial estimated savings. With mileage under 25,000 miles, it represents excellent value for a recent model year, especially considering its price point.
This 2021 Performance model offers a decent deal score, though its estimated savings are modest. It has accumulated a higher mileage (nearly 49,000 miles) but has been on the market for 52 days, which might indicate room for negotiation on its price.
This 2021 Performance model presents a good deal score, and its relatively short time on market (21 days) suggests it's a desirable listing. While the mileage is approaching 50,000, the price is competitive for its year and trim.
This 2023 Performance model is a standout deal, offering substantial estimated savings and a good deal score. With mileage under 35,000 miles, it represents excellent value for a recent model year, especially given its attractive price and moderate time on market.
This 2023 Performance model offers a good deal score with mileage under 22,000 miles. While the estimated savings are modest, its price is competitive for a vehicle of this age and condition, and it has been on the market for a moderate duration.
This 2021 Performance model has a decent deal score, and its price is attractive for its year. While it has nearly 50,000 miles, its short time on market (18 days) suggests it's a desirable listing that might move quickly.
This 2021 Performance model offers a good deal score and estimated savings. With mileage under 37,000 miles, it's a solid option for its year, and its very short time on market (10 days) suggests it's priced attractively and likely to sell fast.
This 2023 Performance model offers a good deal score with mileage under 26,000 miles. While the estimated savings are moderate, its price is competitive for a recent model year, and it has been on the market for a reasonable duration.
Last analyzed: March 5, 2026