Why Porsche Believes EVs Should Ditch Fake Gear Changes for Good

As the automotive industry undergoes a seismic shift towards electric vehicles (EVs), the driving experience is evolving in surprising ways. With the advent of sophisticated electric powertrains, the need for traditional gear changes is often under scrutiny. Some manufacturers, such as Hyundai with its innovative Ioniq 5 N, have embraced the idea of simulating manual gear changes to retain that 'traditional' feel. However, Porsche’s development driver, Lars Kern, stands firmly against this trend. Drawing a line in the sand, Porsche believes that introducing fake gear changes into the EV experience dampens the essence of what electric motors are capable of achieving.

The Evolution of Driving Dynamics

For decades, the thrill of driving a high-performance car has been closely linked to mastering the manual transmission. The subtle nuances of shifting gears, feeling the kinetic response, and engaging with the engine’s power band are experiential elements that enthusiasts cherish. With the rise of electrification, many wonder if this cherished interaction should be preserved or evolve. Kern argues that electric motors, with their unique power delivery characteristics and instantaneous torque, already offer a superior driving dynamic compared to internal combustion engines (ICE).

Understanding Porsche's Perspective on Gear Simulation

Porsche’s philosophy stands out particularly amidst a landscape where other manufacturers are experimenting with artificial gear changes. According to Kern, “there’s no reason to simulate what has been in the past.” This statement encapsulates Porsche's vision for the future of its electric models. Instead of artificially mimicking the past, the company aims to harness the unique advantages of EV technology. By focusing on the advancements electric motors provide, Porsche seeks to redefine performance rather than replicate it.

The Great Debate: Tradition vs. Innovation

The car world is fraught with debates about tradition versus innovation. While many brands cling to analog characteristics, Porsche has been clear about its forward-thinking approach. The Taycan, one of its flagship electric vehicles, features a two-speed transmission tailored for both rapid acceleration from a standstill and efficiency at higher speeds. It demonstrates that Porsche embraces technology while still respecting the essence of automotive performance.

“We don’t want to fake the combustion engine because we still produce combustion engines,” said Kern. This resonates with a brand ethos deeply rooted in performance and purity.

The Allure of Fake Gear Changes

While Porsche opts to reject simulated gear shifts, some manufacturers leverage this feature to capture the hearts of traditional enthusiasts. The Hyundai Ioniq 5 N’s “N e-Shift” function is a prime example, offering an artificial eight-speed experience designed to evoke nostalgic sensations. However, Porsche explored this idea briefly before rejecting it, indicating the absence of prototypes that met their performance standards.

What Lies Ahead for Porsche's Electrified Lineup

Porsche is committed to transitioning its lineup towards electric power without compromising the dynamics that define the brand. Vehicles such as the Macan, Boxster, and Cayman staple models will eventually evolve into electric forms while maintaining the brand's unique DNA. The next-generation Cayenne is also poised to join the EV fold. However, the ambitious goal set in 2022 for EVs to comprise over 80% of annual sales has been reassessed, reflecting a more cautious approach based on market demands and technological developments.

The Balancing Act of Transitioning

Porsche’s strategic pivot towards electrification illustrates a broader trend within the industry. As automakers navigate the transition from ICE to EVs, they must balance innovation with legacy. Kern acknowledges this transitional period is taking longer than anticipated and stresses the importance of preserving core driving experiences that enthusiasts expect from the brand. Even with the excitement around new technologies, the soul of driving should not be lost.

Conclusion: A Future without Fake Gear Changes

Porsche’s decision to steer clear of artificial gear changes embodies a visionary philosophy grounded in taking full advantage of modern EV capabilities. Driving an electric Porsche means embracing a new era where responsiveness and direct interaction with the powertrain will define the future of performance driving. As the automotive landscape continues to evolve, Porsche is determined to ensure that it leads the charge—staying true to its roots while blazing a trail into the electric future.