Compare prices within the same model year
2009
The market for these Porsche 911 models shows a broad price distribution, with significant value found in well-maintained examples. While there are high-priced listings, many excellent deals exist in the $50,000 to $90,000 range, especially for Carrera S models. Prices are generally stable, with a clear premium for lower mileage and desirable specifications.
Moderate
The Porsche 911 market within the 2008-2012 range presents a wide spectrum of pricing, from entry-level options to premium examples. While the average price hovers around $81,800 with about 52,000 miles, deals can be found significantly below this. Buyers should prioritize condition and maintenance history, as these factors heavily influence value and future ownership costs. Patience is key, as some listings have been on the market for an extended period, indicating potential negotiation room. Consider the Carrera S trim for a strong balance of performance and value.
This deal stands out with a high deal score, offering significant estimated savings and a very attractive price point for a 2009 Carrera S with relatively low mileage. While it has been on the market longer, its overall value proposition is excellent.
This 2011 Carrera S is a top contender due to its exceptionally low mileage, which is significantly below the market average. It represents a premium example with a strong deal score, making it a highly desirable option for buyers prioritizing condition.
This 2011 Carrera S is an outstanding deal, featuring the lowest mileage among the top recommendations and offering substantial estimated savings. Its high deal score reflects its exceptional value for a car in such pristine condition.
This 2011 Carrera S offers exceptional value with a high deal score and one of the largest estimated savings in the list. Its mileage is well below average, making it a strong contender for buyers seeking a great deal on a well-maintained vehicle.
This 2009 Carrera S offers a good balance of price and mileage, falling within a competitive range. While the estimated savings are modest, its solid deal score indicates it's a well-priced vehicle for its condition and year.
This 2012 Carrera S is a strong contender, boasting very low mileage for its year and a good deal score. While the estimated savings are modest, the low mileage makes it a premium offering.
This 2008 Carrera S is priced attractively and offers a good deal score. While the estimated savings are not the highest, its competitive price for the mileage makes it a solid choice for budget-conscious buyers.
This 2008 Carrera S offers one of the best estimated savings on the list and a good deal score, making it a compelling value proposition. While mileage is slightly above average, the price point is very attractive.
This 2012 Carrera S offers substantial estimated savings and a reasonable mileage for its year. The longer days on market suggest potential flexibility from the seller, making it a good candidate for negotiation.
This 2008 Carrera S is one of the most affordable options on the list, offering a solid deal score for its price. While mileage is higher than average, it represents a good entry point into 911 ownership.
This 2012 Carrera S stands out with its very low mileage, which is a significant plus. While the estimated savings are modest, the low mileage and recent listing suggest it's a well-priced, high-quality example.
This 2009 Carrera S offers a good balance of price and mileage, with a decent deal score. The estimated savings are moderate, but it represents a solid option for those looking for a 911 from this era.
This 2008 Carrera S is a standout for its exceptional estimated savings, making it the most affordable option with significant discount potential. While mileage is higher, the price point and savings are very attractive.
This 2012 Carrera S is highlighted by its extremely low mileage, indicating a car that has been driven sparingly and likely well-cared for. Although estimated savings are negligible, its condition and low mileage make it a premium offering.
This 2009 Carrera S offers a reasonable price for its mileage and year. While the estimated savings are minimal, its deal score indicates it's a fairly priced vehicle, making it a decent option for buyers not prioritizing maximum savings.
Last analyzed: October 1, 2026