Ferrari 458 Italia
AI Analyzed

Ferrari 458 Italia

Overall Average Market Price
$411,526
Range: $240,194 - $1,339,973

Average Price by Year

Compare prices within the same model year

2010
$469,607
22,572 mi avg
11 listings
2011
$393,598
17,987 mi avg
9 listings
2012
$375,922
21,680 mi avg
7 listings
2013
$338,659
16,978 mi avg
3 listings
2014
$404,990
19,784 mi avg
6 listings
2015
$418,904
18,502 mi avg
4 listings
40
Active Listings
20,140
Overall Avg Mileage
57
Days on Market

Market Insights

Best Value Year

2010

Price Trend

The market for the Ferrari 458 Italia is dynamic, with prices ranging significantly from $240k to over $1.3M. While the average price sits around $411k, there are numerous opportunities to acquire vehicles well below this mark, particularly for earlier model years (like 2010) with moderate mileage. Newer models or exceptionally low-mileage examples command a premium. The presence of deals with substantial estimated savings suggests that strategic buyers can find excellent value.

Inventory Level

Moderate

Buyer Advice

The Ferrari 458 Italia market shows considerable price variation, indicating that careful selection based on mileage, condition, and specific options is crucial. With 40 listings available, patience can be rewarded, but top-tier deals move relatively quickly. Focus on vehicles with lower mileage and a strong service history to maximize long-term value. Be prepared to negotiate, especially on listings that have been on the market longer, as there's often room for discussion.

Top 15 Recommended Deals

Best Deal
#1
Deal 1
2010 $379,988
Save ~$89,619
7,028 mi Salt Lake City, UT 2010
Ferrari of Salt Lake City
Deal Score: 96%

This deal stands out with the highest deal score, offering substantial estimated savings of nearly $90,000 below the market average. The vehicle has exceptionally low mileage for its year (7,028 miles) and has been on the market for a reasonable 34 days, indicating strong value.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7A0176050
View Listing
#2
Deal 2
2015 $369,000
Save ~$49,904
7,354 mi Nebraska City, NE 2015
Henry Motors South
Deal Score: 96%

This deal boasts the same top-tier deal score as rank 1, featuring a newer model year (2015) with very low mileage (7,354 miles). While it has been on the market longer (271 days), the price of $369,000 offers substantial savings, making it a standout opportunity for a more recent 458 Italia.

VIN: ZFF67NFA2F0209737
View Listing
#3
Deal 3
2010 $450,313
Save ~$19,294
8,284 mi Lake Bluff, IL 2010
Zeigler Ferrari of Lake Forest
Deal Score: 76%

This 2010 model is highly recommended due to its exceptionally low mileage (8,284 miles) and very short time on the market (9 days), suggesting it's a desirable vehicle. While the estimated savings are modest, the combination of low mileage and quick turnover indicates a well-priced and sought-after example.

VIN: ZFF67NFA0A0175354
View Listing
#4
Deal 4
2010 $400,080
Save ~$69,527
16,976 mi Beverly Hills, CA 2010
TBTFW
Deal Score: 73%

This 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia offers substantial estimated savings of nearly $70,000 and has been on the market for only 11 days. With 16,976 miles, it strikes a good balance between usage and value, making it a compelling option.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7A0175884
View Listing
#5
Deal 5
2010 $395,849
Save ~$73,758
20,822 mi Boerne, TX 2010
Mark Motors
Deal Score: 70%

This 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia offers significant estimated savings of over $73,000 and has been on the market for 17 days. With 20,822 miles, it's a well-balanced option for buyers seeking value in a slightly higher mileage but still very capable example.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7A0174122
View Listing
#6
Deal 6
2010 $408,888
Save ~$60,719
16,300 mi Phoenix, AZ 2010
ZTR Autohaus
Deal Score: 70%

This 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia is a great find, with substantial estimated savings of over $60,000 and only 16,300 miles. Its very short time on market (5 days) suggests it's a highly desirable vehicle, making it a strong contender for a quick purchase.

VIN: ZFF67NFA6A0176086
View Listing
#7
Deal 7
2010 $385,000
Save ~$84,607
25,385 mi Greensboro, NC 2010
Foreign Cars Italia (Now Hendrick)
Deal Score: 68%

This 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia offers one of the largest estimated savings at over $84,000. While it has higher mileage (25,385 miles), its aggressive pricing and 23-day market presence make it a compelling value proposition for buyers prioritizing savings.

VIN: ZFF67NFA2A0175128
View Listing
#8
Deal 8
2015 $400,590
Save ~$18,314
18,276 mi Bayside, NY 2015
SR Auto Group
Deal Score: 67%

This 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia is a good option for those seeking a newer model year. Despite modest estimated savings, it has accumulated 18,276 miles and has been on the market for a considerable 137 days, suggesting potential negotiation leverage.

VIN: ZFF67NFAXF0210456
View Listing
#9
Deal 9
2014 $374,581
Save ~$30,409
19,703 mi Tampa, FL 2014
Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing
Deal Score: 62%

This 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia offers a good balance of mileage (19,703 miles) and estimated savings ($30,409). Its 17-day market presence indicates it's a reasonably priced vehicle that might offer some room for negotiation.

VIN: ZFF67NFA5E0201520
View Listing
#10
Deal 10
2014 $394,990
Save ~$10,000
15,644 mi Denver, CO 2014
Drake Motor Cars
Deal Score: 58%

This 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia has relatively low mileage (15,644 miles) and has been on the market for 14 days. While the estimated savings are minimal, its condition and quick turnover suggest it's a solid, fairly priced vehicle.

VIN: ZFF67NFAXE0196850
View Listing
#11
Deal 11
2012 $351,696
Save ~$24,226
19,726 mi Miami, FL 2012
Prestige Imports
Deal Score: 58%

This 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia is priced attractively at $351,696, offering estimated savings of over $24,000. With 19,726 miles and 79 days on the market, there may be room for negotiation on this well-positioned vehicle.

VIN: ZFF67NFA6C0183171
View Listing
#12
Deal 12
2010 $399,990
Save ~$69,617
30,392 mi Momence, IL 2010
Route 1 Chevrolet
Deal Score: 54%

This 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia offers substantial estimated savings of nearly $70,000. Although it has higher mileage (30,392 miles) and has been on the market for a very long time (882 days), the aggressive pricing makes it a potential bargain for a buyer comfortable with higher mileage.

VIN: ZFF67NFA4A0175132
View Listing
#13
Deal 13
2011 $329,900
Save ~$63,698
25,838 mi North Charlotte, NC 2011
Tactical Fleet Charlotte
Deal Score: 50%

This 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia is priced very competitively at $329,900, offering substantial estimated savings of over $63,000. With 25,838 miles and 81 days on the market, it represents a strong value opportunity for a buyer looking for a well-priced example.

VIN: ZFF67NFA3B0180775
View Listing
#14
Deal 14
2011 $381,189
Save ~$12,409
17,694 mi Orlando, FL 2011
Ferrari Maserati of Central Florida
Deal Score: 46%

This 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia has a reasonable mileage of 17,694 miles and has been on the market for 26 days. While the estimated savings are lower, its relatively quick sale suggests it's a fairly priced vehicle.

VIN: ZFF67NFA6B0176994
View Listing
#15
Deal 15
2011 $338,581
Save ~$55,017
23,403 mi Tampa, FL 2011
Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing
Deal Score: 45%

This 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia is priced at $338,581, offering estimated savings of over $55,000. With 23,403 miles and a short 18-day market presence, it represents a solid value for a buyer looking for a well-priced example.

VIN: ZFF67NFA6B0176283
View Listing
πŸ”’

Unlock All Premium Deals

See the exact VINs, dealer contacts, and negotiation strategies that could save you $15,000+

βœ“ Full dealer info
βœ“ Negotiation tips
βœ“ Price history
βœ“ Market alerts
Customer
"Found my Ferrari 488 for $22k below market using these exact deals!"
- Michael R.
Customer
"Saved $18,000 on my Lamborghini HuracΓ‘n. The AI found deals I never would have seen."
- Sarah K.
Customer
"Got my Porsche 911 GT3 for $35k under asking. This service pays for itself!"
- David L.
30-day money-back guarantee

Last analyzed: September 1, 2026