Ferrari 458 Italia
AI Analyzed

Ferrari 458 Italia

Overall Average Market Price
$384,516
Range: $195,889 - $1,332,973

Average Price by Year

Compare prices within the same model year

2010
$425,730
23,234 mi avg
14 listings
2011
$320,165
26,014 mi avg
10 listings
2012
$358,446
26,254 mi avg
7 listings
2013
$352,494
14,554 mi avg
4 listings
2014
$384,834
18,337 mi avg
9 listings
2015
$459,358
14,220 mi avg
5 listings
49
Active Listings
21,705
Overall Avg Mileage
61
Days on Market

Market Insights

Best Value Year

2010

Price Trend

The Ferrari 458 Italia market is robust, with prices holding steady for well-preserved examples. While there's a broad spectrum of pricing, listings that have been on the market longer or offer significant savings compared to the average are prime opportunities. The average price sits around $384,515, with a wide dispersion indicating that condition and specific options play a significant role in valuation.

Inventory Level

Moderate

Buyer Advice

The Ferrari 458 Italia market shows a strong demand for well-maintained examples, with a wide price range reflecting mileage, condition, and year. Buyers looking for the best value should focus on models from 2010-2012, which often present a compelling balance of performance and price. Be prepared for a competitive market, as inventory is relatively limited. Patience and a strategic approach to negotiation, leveraging market data and days on market, will be key to securing a favorable deal.

Top 15 Recommended Deals

Best Deal
#1
Deal 1
2014 $330,497
Save ~$54,337
7,205 mi Las Vegas, NV 2014
The Collezione By THECARWIZ
Deal Score: 92%

This deal is exceptional due to its high deal score, significant estimated savings, and remarkably low mileage for its year. It represents a prime opportunity to acquire a relatively recent model 458 Italia in excellent condition at a price well below the market average.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7E0197910
View Listing
#2
Deal 2
2010 $410,313
Save ~$15,417
8,284 mi Lake Bluff, IL 2010
Ferrari Lake Forest
Deal Score: 91%

This 2010 model is highly recommended due to its exceptionally low mileage, suggesting it has been meticulously cared for. While the estimated savings are modest, the overall package of a well-preserved, low-mileage supercar at a competitive price makes it a standout deal.

VIN: ZFF67NFA0A0175354
View Listing
#3
Deal 3
2010 $390,080
Save ~$35,650
16,976 mi Beverly Hills, CA 2010
TBTFW
Deal Score: 89%

This 2010 458 Italia offers a compelling combination of a desirable year, reasonable mileage, and significant estimated savings. Its presence on the market for over a month suggests potential flexibility for negotiation.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7A0175884
View Listing
#4
Deal 4
2010 $388,000
Save ~$37,730
16,300 mi Phoenix, AZ 2010
ZTR Autohaus
Deal Score: 89%

This 2010 458 Italia is a strong contender, offering a good balance of mileage, estimated savings, and a reasonable time on the market. It represents a solid value for a supercar of this caliber.

VIN: ZFF67NFA6A0176086
View Listing
#5
Deal 5
2010 $276,581
Save ~$149,149
13,821 mi Tampa, FL 2010
Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing
Deal Score: 87%

This deal is outstanding due to its remarkably high estimated savings and low mileage, making it the best value proposition among the top-ranked vehicles. Its short time on the market suggests strong interest, but the savings potential is significant.

VIN: ZFF67NFA5A0175348
View Listing
#6
Deal 6
2010 $385,489
Save ~$40,241
17,443 mi Saint Louis, MO 2010
Cavallino Rosso
Deal Score: 81%

This 2010 458 Italia is a strong choice, offering a good balance of mileage, significant estimated savings, and a relatively short time on the market, indicating a potentially motivated seller.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7A0173665
View Listing
#7
Deal 7
2010 $365,951
Save ~$59,779
20,822 mi Boerne, TX 2010
Mark Motors
Deal Score: 80%

This 2010 458 Italia stands out with its substantial estimated savings and a solid deal score. While mileage is slightly higher than some others, the overall value proposition is strong, especially considering its time on the market.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7A0174122
View Listing
#8
Deal 8
2010 $326,581
Save ~$99,149
21,290 mi Tampa, FL 2010
Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing
Deal Score: 77%

This 2010 458 Italia offers a significant amount of estimated savings, making it an attractive option. Its moderate time on the market and reasonable mileage for its age contribute to its strong recommendation.

VIN: ZFF67NFA2A0176151
View Listing
#9
Deal 9
2014 $343,581
Save ~$41,253
19,703 mi Tampa, FL 2014
Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing
Deal Score: 73%

This 2014 458 Italia offers a good balance of a more recent model year, reasonable mileage, and solid estimated savings. Its time on the market suggests there may be room for negotiation.

VIN: ZFF67NFA5E0201520
View Listing
#10
Deal 10
2012 $346,696
Save ~$11,750
19,725 mi Miami, FL 2012
Prestige Imports
Deal Score: 66%

This 2012 458 Italia is a decent option, particularly due to its longer time on the market (109 days), which often indicates a seller's willingness to negotiate. The mileage is also within a reasonable range for its age.

VIN: ZFF67NFA6C0183171
View Listing
#11
Deal 11
2010 $399,990
Save ~$25,740
30,392 mi Momence, IL 2010
Route 1 Chevrolet
Deal Score: 52%

This 2010 458 Italia is notable primarily for its extremely long days on market (912 days), which strongly suggests the seller is highly motivated to make a deal. The higher mileage is offset by this factor, making it a potential bargain if negotiated effectively.

VIN: ZFF67NFA4A0175132
View Listing
#12
Deal 12
2015 $426,125
Save ~$33,233
22,127 mi Plano, TX 2015
Ferrari Dallas
Deal Score: 49%

This 2015 458 Italia is a more recent model year, which can be attractive. While the deal score is lower, it still offers some estimated savings and has been on the market for a moderate duration.

VIN: ZFF67NFA5F0210607
View Listing
#13
Deal 13
2015 $400,765
Save ~$58,593
18,276 mi Bayside, NY 2015
SR Auto Group
Deal Score: 48%

This 2015 458 Italia offers substantial estimated savings and reasonable mileage. Its extended time on the market (167 days) suggests a motivated seller, making it a good candidate for negotiation.

VIN: ZFF67NFAx F0210456
View Listing
#14
Deal 14
2011 $259,990
Save ~$60,175
44,199 mi West Hollywood, CA 2011
Specialty Car Collection
Deal Score: 47%

This 2011 458 Italia presents a significant opportunity due to its high estimated savings and extended days on market (105 days). The higher mileage is a factor, but the potential for a substantial discount makes it worth considering.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7B0176521
View Listing
#15
Deal 15
2011 $309,900
Save ~$10,265
25,845 mi North Charlotte, NC 2011
Tactical Fleet Charlotte
Deal Score: 46%

This 2011 458 Italia is a solid option, particularly given its extended time on the market (111 days), which may indicate seller flexibility. The mileage is within a reasonable range for its age, and it offers a modest estimated saving.

VIN: ZFF67NFA3B0180775
View Listing
πŸ”’

Unlock All Premium Deals

See the exact VINs, dealer contacts, and negotiation strategies that could save you $15,000+

βœ“ Full dealer info
βœ“ Negotiation tips
βœ“ Price history
βœ“ Market alerts
Customer
"Found my Ferrari 488 for $22k below market using these exact deals!"
- Michael R.
Customer
"Saved $18,000 on my Lamborghini HuracΓ‘n. The AI found deals I never would have seen."
- Sarah K.
Customer
"Got my Porsche 911 GT3 for $35k under asking. This service pays for itself!"
- David L.
30-day money-back guarantee

Last analyzed: October 1, 2026