Ferrari 458 Italia
AI Analyzed

Ferrari 458 Italia

Overall Average Market Price
$214,534
Range: $159,989 - $285,000

Average Price by Year

Compare prices within the same model year

2010
$211,085
19,703 mi avg
8 listings
2011
$213,424
24,332 mi avg
11 listings
2012
$203,199
31,290 mi avg
4 listings
2013
$198,995
17,147 mi avg
2 listings
2014
$239,724
18,534 mi avg
4 listings
2015
$229,995
17,699 mi avg
1 listings
30
Active Listings
22,552
Overall Avg Mileage
104
Days on Market

Market Insights

Best Value Year

2010

Price Trend

The market for the Ferrari 458 Italia appears stable with significant price variation based on year, mileage, and condition. While the average price hovers around $214,500, deals can be found substantially below this, indicating strong opportunities for value-conscious buyers. Newer models (2013-2014) generally sit at the higher end, while earlier models (2010-2012) offer a lower entry price, often with higher mileage.

Inventory Level

Moderate

Buyer Advice

The Ferrari 458 Italia market shows a wide range of pricing and mileage, offering opportunities for various budgets. While newer models command higher prices, earlier model years (2010-2012) often present a more accessible entry point, especially if you're willing to consider slightly higher mileage. Inventory is moderate, so acting decisively on well-priced examples is advisable. Focus on vehicles with comprehensive service history and consider pre-purchase inspections, particularly for higher-mileage examples.

Top 15 Recommended Deals

Best Deal
#1
Deal 1
2013 $179,995
Save ~$19,000
6,250 mi Omaha, NE 2013
The Internet Car Lot (Omaha)
Deal Score: 96%

This is an outstanding deal, offering a relatively newer model year (2013) with exceptionally low mileage (6,250 miles) at a price significantly below the average market value. The estimated savings are substantial, making it the top-ranked opportunity.

VIN: ZFF67NFA8D0191497
View Listing
#2
Deal 2
2010 $194,900
Save ~$16,185
15,104 mi Houston, TX 2010
Autodynamics, Inc
Deal Score: 90%

This 2010 model offers a strong combination of relatively low mileage (15,104 miles) and a price point that provides significant estimated savings, making it a high-value proposition.

VIN: ZFF67NFA6A0176041
View Listing
#3
Deal 3
2010 $188,991
Save ~$22,094
16,800 mi Scottsdale, AZ 2010
Auto Boom Motor Co.
Deal Score: 84%

This 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia stands out due to its attractive price point and significant estimated savings, coupled with reasonable mileage (16,800 miles) for its model year. It's been on the market for a moderate 54 days.

VIN: ZFF67NFA4A0175910
View Listing
#4
Deal 4
2014 $236,995
Save ~$2,729
10,300 mi Buford, GA 2014
Iconic Auto Group
Deal Score: 74%

This 2014 model is a great option for buyers prioritizing a newer year and very low mileage (10,300 miles). Although the estimated savings are modest, its condition and year make it a desirable choice, and it has been on the market for 183 days, suggesting potential negotiation room.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7E0203270
View Listing
#5
Deal 5
2010 $208,895
Save ~$2,190
14,666 mi Orlando, FL 2010
Ferrari Maserati of Central Florida
Deal Score: 71%

This 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia offers a good balance of low mileage (14,666 miles) and a competitive price, making it a solid choice. Its relatively short time on the market (44 days) suggests strong interest, but there's still potential for negotiation.

VIN: ZFF67NFA0A0175757
View Listing
#6
Deal 6
2012 $169,995
Save ~$33,204
37,040 mi Joliet, IL 2012
Motor Cars of Chicago
Deal Score: 60%

This 2012 model is a standout for its aggressive pricing, offering the highest estimated savings ($33,204) among the top deals. While it has higher mileage (37,040 miles), the price makes it a compelling value proposition for buyers prioritizing affordability.

VIN: ZFF67NFA3C0185881
View Listing
#7
Deal 7
2010 $199,995
Save ~$11,090
17,900 mi Joliet, IL 2010
Motor Cars of Chicago
Deal Score: 59%

This 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia presents a solid option with reasonable mileage (17,900 miles) and a competitive price. Its very short time on the market (23 days) suggests it's a desirable listing.

VIN: ZFF67NFA6A0175293
View Listing
#8
Deal 8
2012 $159,989
Save ~$43,210
65,265 mi Johnson Creek, WI 2012
Kearns Motor Car Co
Deal Score: 48%

This 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia is the most affordable option listed, boasting the highest estimated savings ($43,210). It's ideal for buyers prioritizing a lower purchase price, despite its higher mileage (65,265 miles).

VIN: ZFF67NFA7C0186712
View Listing
#9
Deal 9
2010 $196,995
Save ~$14,090
38,324 mi Orlando, FL 2010
Exotic Knights
Deal Score: 45%

This 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia offers a competitive price with decent estimated savings. While it has higher mileage (38,324 miles), it remains a solid option for those seeking value in an earlier model year.

VIN: ZFF67NFA3A0175039
View Listing
#10
Deal 10
2014 $212,000
Save ~$27,724
35,200 mi Van Nuys, CA 2014
Power to Weight Motorsport
Deal Score: 44%

This 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia presents a unique opportunity with significant estimated savings ($27,724) for a newer model year, despite having higher mileage (35,200 miles). It's been on the market for 93 days, suggesting room for negotiation.

VIN: ZFF67NFA3E0199959
View Listing
#11
Deal 11
2014 $224,900
Save ~$14,824
23,500 mi Glenshaw, PA 2014
Exceptional Motorcars
Deal Score: 38%

This 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia is a well-maintained option with reasonable mileage (23,500 miles) for its year. Its very short time on the market (17 days) suggests it's a desirable listing.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7E0198586
View Listing
#12
Deal 12
2011 $189,995
Save ~$23,429
34,155 mi Joliet, IL 2011
Motor Cars of Chicago
Deal Score: 37%

This 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia offers a good balance of price and estimated savings. While it has higher mileage (34,155 miles), the price point makes it an attractive option for value-conscious buyers.

VIN: ZFF67NFA5B0176520
View Listing
#13
Deal 13
2011 $199,990
Save ~$13,434
29,076 mi Troutdale, OR 2011
Diplomat Motors
Deal Score: 32%

This 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia is a well-presented option with reasonable mileage (29,076 miles). Its very short time on the market (11 days) suggests it's a highly desirable listing.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7B0177300
View Listing
#14
Deal 14
2011 $184,950
Save ~$28,474
29,234 mi Pompano Beach, FL 2011
The New Auto Toy Store
Deal Score: 28%

This 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia offers a strong combination of significant estimated savings ($28,474) and reasonable mileage (29,234 miles). Its very short time on the market (5 days) indicates high demand.

VIN: ZFF67NFA6B0177160
View Listing
#15
Deal 15
2011 $177,950
Save ~$35,474
41,126 mi Pompano Beach, FL 2011
The New Auto Toy Store
Deal Score: 28%

This 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia offers substantial estimated savings ($35,474), making it a very compelling value proposition for buyers focused on affordability, despite its higher mileage (41,126 miles). Its very short time on the market (5 days) suggests high demand.

VIN: ZFF67NFA6B0177515
View Listing
πŸ”’

Unlock All Premium Deals

See the exact VINs, dealer contacts, and negotiation strategies that could save you $15,000+

βœ“ Full dealer info
βœ“ Negotiation tips
βœ“ Price history
βœ“ Market alerts
Customer
"Found my Ferrari 488 for $22k below market using these exact deals!"
- Michael R.
Customer
"Saved $18,000 on my Lamborghini HuracΓ‘n. The AI found deals I never would have seen."
- Sarah K.
Customer
"Got my Porsche 911 GT3 for $35k under asking. This service pays for itself!"
- David L.
30-day money-back guarantee

Last analyzed: November 3, 2025