Compare prices within the same model year
2009
With only 4 total listings in the specified range, the market is very tight. Prices are currently holding firm, with a significant spread between the lowest and highest examples, suggesting condition and mileage are key differentiators. The average price is skewed by higher-end listings, making well-maintained, lower-mileage examples at or below the average a particularly good find.
Low
The Cadillac XLR market is quite niche, with limited inventory. Given the current low number of listings, buyers should act decisively when a well-priced example appears. The 2009 model year, particularly the Platinum trim, appears to offer strong value, balancing modern features with potentially lower depreciation compared to earlier years. Be prepared for a competitive situation if a desirable vehicle surfaces.
This is the top-ranked deal due to its excellent combination of a desirable 2009 Platinum trim, very low mileage for its age, and a price significantly below the average market price, resulting in substantial estimated savings. It also has a reasonable days on market, indicating good market appeal.
This deal is highly recommended due to its exceptionally low price, which is the lowest in the market and offers the largest estimated savings. Despite having higher mileage, its aggressive pricing and very short time on market make it a standout value opportunity for a buyer prioritizing cost savings.
Last analyzed: November 2, 2025