Compare prices within the same model year
2002
The market for these BMW M5s shows significant price stratification. While the average price is around $58,600, listings range from under $20,000 to over $155,000. This indicates that pristine, low-mileage examples command a premium, while higher-mileage or less-than-perfect condition cars are available at much lower price points. The high average days on market (over 200) suggests that sellers may be holding firm on prices, or that buyers are highly selective, leading to longer sales cycles. Deals with substantial estimated savings often involve higher mileage or longer time on market, presenting opportunities for savvy negotiators.
Moderate
The BMW M5 market from 1998-2003 (E39 generation) presents a wide spectrum of opportunities, with prices varying significantly based on condition, mileage, and maintenance history. Inventory appears moderate, but vehicles can take a considerable time to sell, suggesting buyers have room for negotiation if they are patient and well-informed. Focus on vehicles with comprehensive service records, as these iconic supersedans require diligent upkeep. The 2002 model year often strikes a good balance between later-model refinements and value. Be prepared for a broad price range, and don't shy away from vehicles with higher mileage if their maintenance history is impeccable, as they can offer substantial savings.
This deal stands out with the highest deal score, indicating excellent value. While it has higher mileage at 122,144, its price of $25,999 is significantly below the average, and it has been on the market for a reasonable 99 days. The estimated savings of $3,501 further solidify its position as a top recommendation.
This 2000 M5 is recommended due to its significantly lower mileage (68,561) compared to the average, suggesting it has been well-preserved. Despite a longer time on market (302 days), its price of $35,998 is still attractive for a lower-mileage example, offering good value.
This 2002 M5 offers substantial estimated savings of $20,399, making it a standout deal. Its mileage of 89,618 is right around the market average, and while it has been on the market for a long time (394 days), its price of $42,800 is well-positioned for a buyer looking for significant value.
This 2003 M5 is a prime example of a well-preserved, low-mileage vehicle, with only 54,801 miles. It offers significant estimated savings of $14,987 and, despite being on the market for 189 days, its price of $74,990 is justified by its condition and mileage, making it a strong contender for enthusiasts.
This 2000 M5 is a good value proposition at $27,995, offering estimated savings of $9,923. While it has higher mileage at 118,804, its price point makes it accessible, and its 200 days on market suggests potential for negotiation.
This 2002 M5 offers one of the largest estimated savings at $25,209. With 102,058 miles, it's within a reasonable range for its age, and its 114 days on market indicates it's been available for a while, potentially opening the door for negotiation on its $37,990 price.
This 2002 M5 is a strong contender due to its impressive estimated savings of $25,399, the highest among the top deals. With 109,856 miles, it's a solid driver-quality example, and its 115 days on market suggests potential for negotiation on the $37,800 asking price.
This 2002 M5 stands out with the second-highest estimated savings at $35,209. While it has higher mileage at 122,099, its price of $27,990 is very competitive, and its long 254 days on market indicates a strong negotiation potential.
This 2003 M5 is a great find with only 75,761 miles, significantly below the average, and offers substantial estimated savings of $24,987. Its price of $64,990 is competitive for its mileage, and the 207 days on market suggests room for negotiation.
This 2002 M5 presents the highest estimated savings at $38,249, making it an exceptional value for its price of $24,950. While it has high mileage at 149,544, its long 670 days on market strongly indicates significant negotiation potential.
This 2000 M5 is the lowest-priced option at $19,995, offering significant estimated savings of $17,923. It has higher mileage at 132,992, but its extremely long 722 days on market suggests considerable room for negotiation.
This 2002 M5 offers excellent estimated savings of $28,249. With 109,326 miles, it's a well-priced option at $34,950. The fact that it has only been on the market for 24 days suggests it's moving quickly, but its strong value proposition still warrants an offer.
This 2000 M5 is priced at $34,999 with 137,733 miles. While the estimated savings are modest, its relatively short 66 days on market suggests it's a fairly priced vehicle that might not have extensive negotiation room, but still represents a decent option.
This 2003 M5 is a low-mileage gem with only 65,173 miles, offering substantial estimated savings of $14,987. Its price of $74,990 is competitive for such a well-preserved example, and its short 31 days on market indicates strong buyer interest.
This 2000 M5 is priced at $24,995 with 134,736 miles, offering estimated savings of $12,923. While it has higher mileage, its price point makes it an accessible option, and its 105 days on market suggests there may be some room for negotiation.
Last analyzed: November 2, 2025