Compare prices within the same model year
2011
The market for this generation of BMW M3 exhibits significant price variation. While the average price hovers around $44.5k, the presence of listings below $30k and above $70k indicates that factors like mileage, condition, and specific options heavily influence value. There's a clear opportunity for buyers to find significant savings by targeting well-maintained vehicles that may have been on the market longer or are priced below the peak market value.
Low
The BMW M3 market, particularly for the E90/E92/E93 generation, shows a wide price spectrum reflecting condition, mileage, and maintenance history. With a limited total inventory of 18 listings and an average of 96 days on market, opportunities can be competitive. Buyers should prioritize vehicles with thorough service records and consider that lower-priced examples often come with higher mileage, requiring a careful assessment of potential future maintenance costs. The 2011 model year appears to offer a strong balance of modern features and value, especially when found at a competitive price point.
This is the top-ranked deal, boasting an excellent deal score of 0.73. It offers a relatively low mileage of 60,059 miles for a 2011 model, combined with significant estimated savings of $11,147. Its price is just slightly above the market average but is justified by its condition and mileage.
This deal stands out due to its aggressive pricing at $29,950, making it one of the most affordable options. While it has higher mileage (113,757 miles), its deal score of 0.65 and ranking suggest it's a solid value proposition for someone prioritizing a lower entry price for the M3 experience.
This deal offers exceptional value with the highest estimated savings ($27,052) among the top deals and a very reasonable mileage of 79,929 miles for a 2011 model. Its strong deal score and ranking reflect this excellent combination of price and condition.
This is one of the most affordable M3 sedans available at $23,995, with a deal score of 0.48. While it has higher mileage (124,871 miles), its quick sale (22 days on market) suggests it's priced attractively for its condition and year.
This is the most budget-friendly option at $21,900, offering significant estimated savings of $11,774. Although it has the highest mileage (142,343 miles) among the top deals, its low price and long days on market (131) make it a strong contender for value-conscious buyers.
This deal offers substantial estimated savings of $17,450 and a reasonable mileage of 88,092 miles for a 2011 model. Its ranking and deal score indicate it's a solid choice for those seeking a good balance of price, mileage, and potential value.
This 2008 M3 sedan is priced competitively at $27,800, with a deal score of 0.35. It has higher mileage (120,667 miles) but has been on the market for a moderate 36 days, suggesting it could be a good value for a buyer looking for an older M3.
This deal offers the second-highest estimated savings ($27,057) and a reasonable mileage of 91,900 miles for a 2011 model. Its quick sale (23 days) indicates strong market interest, making it a good value proposition.
This 2009 M3 sedan is priced at $27,990 and has a deal score of 0.25. It has high mileage (140,542 miles) but has been on the market for a very short time (2 days), suggesting it's priced attractively for its condition and year.
This 2010 M3 sedan is priced at $45,000 with 95,000 miles, offering estimated savings of $10,000. It has been on the market for 75 days, suggesting potential negotiation room for a buyer interested in a mid-mileage example.
This 2012 M3 sedan is priced at $52,000 with a lower mileage of 70,000 miles, offering estimated savings of $5,000. It has been on the market for 55 days, making it a potentially good option for those seeking a newer model with fewer miles.
This 2009 M3 sedan is priced at $35,000 with 105,000 miles, offering substantial estimated savings of $15,000. It has been on the market for 110 days, suggesting it might be a good candidate for negotiation.
This 2011 M3 sedan is priced at $48,000 with 85,000 miles, offering estimated savings of $8,000. It has been on the market for 68 days, making it a reasonable option for those looking for a mid-mileage example.
This 2008 M3 sedan is priced at $32,000 with 110,000 miles. It has been on the market for 90 days, and while estimated savings are low, its price might appeal to buyers seeking a more affordable entry into M3 ownership.
This 2010 M3 sedan is priced at $50,000 with 75,000 miles, offering estimated savings of $12,000. It has been on the market for 100 days, suggesting it could be a good candidate for negotiation for a buyer looking for a lower-mileage example.
Last analyzed: March 5, 2026