Compare prices within the same model year
2011
The market for this generation of BMW M3 shows a wide price spectrum, from entry-level options under $20,000 to premium, low-mileage examples exceeding $200,000. This indicates strong demand for well-maintained and enthusiast-owned vehicles, with prices generally stable for average examples but appreciating for exceptional ones. The average price of $45,844 suggests a healthy market with many vehicles falling into this bracket, while the extensive range points to the impact of mileage, condition, and specific options on overall value.
Moderate
The BMW M3 market within the 2007-2013 range presents a compelling mix of performance and value. While the average price hovers around $45,800 with approximately 67,600 miles, there's significant variation. Buyers should prioritize condition and maintenance history, especially for models with higher mileage. The 2011 model year appears to offer a strong balance of modern features, performance, and value, as seen in the top-ranked deals. Be prepared for a competitive market, as desirable examples can move quickly, but patience can yield significant savings, with some listings offering over $10,000 in estimated savings.
This deal stands out with the highest deal score (0.89) and exceptionally low mileage (32,763 miles) for its year, combined with a significant estimated saving of $6,261. It represents a fantastic opportunity for a well-preserved performance coupe.
Ranked second with a strong deal score of 0.86, this 2011 M3 boasts very low mileage (34,165 miles), making it a highly desirable option. While the estimated savings are smaller, the low mileage indicates excellent condition and potential for long-term value.
This 2013 M3 is a top contender with a deal score of 0.85, offering a remarkable estimated saving of $14,165. Its mileage is very low for a 2013 model (32,993 miles), suggesting it has been exceptionally well-cared for and represents outstanding value.
This 2011 M3 earns a high deal score of 0.84, primarily due to its excellent estimated savings of $7,660 and relatively low mileage of 38,244. It offers a great entry point into M3 ownership with significant value.
This 2011 M3 is a standout deal with a score of 0.81, offering substantial estimated savings of $10,154. Its mileage of 44,947 is reasonable for its age, and the significant discount makes it a compelling value proposition.
This 2013 M3 is an exceptional deal, ranking sixth with a score of 0.81 and boasting the largest estimated savings in the top tier at $17,747. Its mileage of 43,437 is very good for a 2013 model, making it a prime candidate for value-conscious buyers.
This 2011 M3 is a strong contender with a deal score of 0.78 and impressive estimated savings of $10,249. While its mileage (52,303) is slightly higher than some top deals, the substantial discount makes it a very attractive option for buyers seeking value.
This 2008 M3 offers a lower entry price point with a deal score of 0.77. Although it has higher mileage (82,278 miles), the price of $26,995 is attractive, and it still presents a good opportunity for enthusiasts looking for an older, well-regarded M3.
This 2008 M3, with a deal score of 0.77, is priced very competitively at $25,900. While it has higher mileage (91,790 miles), the estimated savings of $4,150 and its older model year make it a budget-friendly option for enthusiasts.
This 2013 M3 stands out with a deal score of 0.74 and exceptionally low mileage of 28,131 miles, which is a major value driver. The estimated savings of $5,347 are solid, making this a great option for someone prioritizing a low-mileage, late-model M3.
This 2008 M3 has a deal score of 0.73 and is priced attractively at $27,665. It has higher mileage (90,771 miles), but its listing by a BMW dealership suggests it may have been well-maintained. The estimated savings are modest, but the overall price point is appealing for an older M3.
This 2013 M3 has a deal score of 0.72 and boasts incredibly low mileage at just 23,000 miles. This makes it a highly desirable vehicle, and the estimated savings of $8,150 are substantial for such a well-preserved example.
This 2009 M3 has a deal score of 0.71 and is priced very attractively at $25,998. It has higher mileage (89,694 miles), but the estimated savings of $6,959 are significant, making it a good value option for those seeking an earlier model year M3.
This 2013 M3 has a deal score of 0.70 and features incredibly low mileage at 19,321 miles, making it a very desirable example. The estimated savings of $4,195 are modest, but the extremely low mileage for a 2013 model is a significant value driver.
This 2013 M3 is an exceptional find, ranking 15th with a deal score of 0.70 but offering the largest estimated savings of $20,257. Its mileage of 55,791 is reasonable, and this price point makes it an incredible value for a later model year M3.
Last analyzed: December 1, 2025